Once you start putting shortcuts on buttons, you'll wonder whether to buy dedicated hardware. There are three main options: a macro pad (a mini keyboard of programmable keys), an LCD-key deck (keys with little screens, like a Stream Deck), and a phone deck (an app on the phone you already own). Here's how they compare in practice.
At a glance
| Macro pad | LCD-key deck | Phone deck | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Feel | Mechanical keys, knobs | Clicky keys | Touchscreen, no tactile feedback |
| Labels | Blank or keycap legends | Icon on each key | Icon + text, any size |
| Pages / layers | Layers (you remember them) | Folders and pages | Pages, unlimited screen space |
| Voice | No | No | Yes (SofaDeck and some others) |
| Cost | Low to mid | Mid to high | Free, or a small one-time upgrade (SofaDeck Pro is $9.99) |
| Works across the room | Wired to the desk (some wireless) | Wired to the desk | Anywhere on your Wi-Fi |
When a macro pad wins
If you press the same five or six keys hundreds of times a day — a video editor's cut and ripple keys, a designer's tool switches, a trader's order shortcuts — nothing beats a physical key you can find without looking. Knobs are also genuinely better than touchscreens for scrubbing timelines and adjusting volume. Options range from simple programmable macro pads to pads with rotary knobs and QMK/VIA-programmable boards that store their mapping on the device.
When an LCD-key deck wins
Screens on the keys solve the macro pad's "what does this do?" problem, and folders give you many pages. Streamers love them for scene switching. They cost more, and you still sit at the desk to use them. Look at LCD-key stream controllers if you want hardware with labels. Our Stream Deck alternatives guide covers the software side.
When a phone deck wins
- You're not at the desk. Couch, bed, standing at a presentation, at an arcade cabinet — a phone goes where you go.
- You want lots of actions. Screen space is effectively unlimited and every button is labeled.
- You want voice. Saying "press Start Stream" is faster than finding it.
- You're not sure yet. A phone deck is the cheapest way to learn which buttons you really use before buying hardware.
Our recommendation
Start with a phone deck for a couple of weeks. Notice which three to six buttons you press without thinking — those are the ones worth moving to physical keys. Keep everything else, and voice, on the phone. That way hardware money goes only on what you've proven you need.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Setting up a streaming layout? See use your phone as a Stream Deck for streaming. Looking for software-only macros? See free macro software for Windows.
Frequently asked questions
What is a macro pad?
A macro pad is a small keyboard with a handful of programmable keys (and sometimes knobs) that you set to shortcuts or sequences — for example one key for mute, another to paste a signature. Unlike a Stream Deck, most macro pads have plain keycaps rather than little screens on each key.
Is a macro pad better than a Stream Deck?
Macro pads are usually cheaper and feel like a mechanical keyboard, but you have to remember what each blank key does. LCD-key decks show an icon on every key and change with pages. Phone decks show labels too and cost nothing extra.
Can I use a phone deck and a macro pad together?
Yes, and many people do: the macro pad for the few keys you press constantly without looking, and a phone deck for the long tail of occasional actions and voice commands.